tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2186213837616167361.post7277996477908556042..comments2022-12-12T14:47:11.471+01:00Comments on 天朝大國: TCE Review on RPG.net賈尼http://www.blogger.com/profile/03207671300903490067noreply@blogger.comBlogger4125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2186213837616167361.post-40677539578218439272013-06-17T15:52:11.053+02:002013-06-17T15:52:11.053+02:00Pues tienes razón, es cierto que parece haberse de...Pues tienes razón, es cierto que parece haberse despistado con el juego del que se nutre The Celestial Empire.Cronistahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07323570345550686034noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2186213837616167361.post-15338555009576244962013-06-14T17:11:11.245+02:002013-06-14T17:11:11.245+02:00Well, if you look at the way the 'Review Summa...Well, if you look at the way the 'Review Summary' is worded, it implies that <i>The Celestial Empire</i> is a RuneQuest 6 supplement — which is wrong. This shows that the reviewer is probably not that familiar with the subtleties of the various D100 systems.<br /><br />Now if we look at the review itself. Of course I'm the author of <i>TCE</i> and — except for the lack of an introductory scenario — I am quite satisfied with my book, but what I've usually been criticised for is that the chapter on Martial Arts (p66) is underdeveloped; the reviewer thinks it's too developed!<br />I also have trouble understanding what the reviewer really thinks of the magic system. Apparently he's implying that my implementation of the RQ6 magic system is lacking; well, <i>TCE</i> is based on BRP, not on RQ6! His words with regards to the Islamic magic section (of which I'm pretty proud despite its brevity) are also quite confusing.<br /><br />But that's nitpicking. The reviewer liked the culture part, which <b>is</b> in my opinion the most important part of the book, so I'm actually quite happy of the review and of the marks.賈尼https://www.blogger.com/profile/03207671300903490067noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2186213837616167361.post-49580069651164483522013-06-14T17:05:46.061+02:002013-06-14T17:05:46.061+02:00Like Cronista, I'm curious about which parts o...Like Cronista, I'm curious about which parts of the game-science you disagree with Kafka about.Gerall Kahlahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09324435667145977126noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2186213837616167361.post-44269184133402292852013-06-14T16:50:32.227+02:002013-06-14T16:50:32.227+02:00Coincide en varios puntos con mis propios comentar...Coincide en varios puntos con mis propios comentarios acerca del libro. Aunque yo no encontré defectos a las mecánicas escogidas, simplemente ocurre que RQ6 me gusta más que BRP. Kafka parece ser de la misma opinión, aunque su juicio sobre Basic RolePlaying parece algo más duro.<br /><br />¿En qué estás en desacuerdo, hablando de la mecánica de reglas?Cronistahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07323570345550686034noreply@blogger.com